The Best Fluffy Pancakes recipe you will fall in love with. Full of tips and tricks to help you make the best pancakes.

CW rushed a great show in Superman and Lois S4
In this episode Y. M. Nelson and guest Perry C. tackle the final season of the CW Arrowverse show, Superman & Lois. They talk about Doomsday, and archnemesis Lex Luthor, and whiy they felt the show was rushed. They also give it a GoodReads rating.
SPOILER ALERT: We will spoil some things in Superman and Lois. So, if you haven’t seen the show, and you don’t want to be spoiled, wait to play the episode.
I first saw these characters in the CW Arrowverse crossover “Crisis of Infinite Earths” while catching up on The Flash. I talk about that in episode 11. However, I didn’t start watching until Perry recommended the show to me as we talked Superheroes in Love on his podcast Superherocinephiles.
See all of my DC Comics reviews.
See Superman and Lois, s1 and S2 review
Topics Discussed (Click to jump to transcript’s section) :
- 1:30 Lex Luthor
- 10:29 Doomsday v. Superman
- 12:12 A rushed ending
- 23:55 The Clark Kent reveal to the world
- 31:42 Kids with superpowers
- 35:28 Where is Superman and Lois in the Arrowverse?
- 40:44 The Last Episode
- 55:08 Goodreads rating
Guest Hosts on this Episode:

Perry Constantine
Born and raised in the Chicagoland area, Percival Constantine grew up on a fairly consistent diet of superhero comics, action movies, video games, and TV shows. At the age of ten, he first began writing and has never really stopped.
Percival has been working in publishing since 2005 in various capacities–author, editor, formatter, letterer–and has written books, short stories, comics, and more. He has a Bachelor of Arts in English and Mass Media from Northeastern Illinois University and a Master of Arts in English and Screenwriting from Southern New Hampshire University.
Currently, Percival lives in southern Japan where he continues to work on new projects and also teaches literature, writing, and film.
Books/graphic novels mentioned on the podcast:
- Urban Fantasy – Dark Crossroads Books
- Comics
Want to contact him?
Website: https://percivalconstantine.com
Superhero Cinephiles – a podcast about superheroes in media hosted by Perry Constantine. Listen wherever you get your podcasts! https://superherocinephiles.com
Where to find books from the podcast:
Support Indie Bookstores by buying at Bookshop!
Click here

*The Bookshop.org link/image above is linked to a list of books reviewed on the podcast . By purchasing a book from there, you support independent book stores, and I will receive a small commission for each purchase when using these links. (This does not affect what you pay.)
Episode Available on
most podcast providers
Don’t have a podcast provider?
Listen to this episode here!
Watch the episode on YouTube
Episode Transcript
Y. M. Nelson: In this episode of Nerdy Romantics Podcast, we will continue our discussion of Superman and Lois Seasons three and four. In particular, we’re gonna talk about season four and the Lex Luther portrayal, what we liked and what we didn’t like about it. We’ll talk about the correlation between this season and the Death Of Superman comic, the Doomsday character, we’ll talk a little bit about some of the scenes that we really liked in this season, and of course we’ll wrap it up with the discussion of the very last episode of this series and give this series and the seasons that we discussed a Goodreads rating.
As with our previous episode, there will be spoilers of Superman and Lois all four seasons.
Y. M. Nelson: So, if you have watched Superman and Lois, please stay tuned.
This is the Nerdy Romantics Podcast and I’m your host, YM Nelson.
[00:01:30] Lex Luthor
Y. M. Nelson: So, season four, we’ve talked a lot about it already. But the one big thing that we haven’t talked about that’s at the top of my list is Lex Luthor, which we thought we were gonna see in season three, but this is season four.
Perry Constantine: Well, we do see him at the end of season three.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, at the end. But season four is really his season.
He’s the big bad in season four. And for me, his the first thing that struck me even in season, ’cause we do see him a little bit at the end of season two and at the end of season three is his look. So, you know, I grew up on the Christopher Reeve Superman. So, you know, Gene Hackman was Lex Luthor in that.
And of course, the most recent kind of iteration I would say would be John Crier being Lex Luthor, you know but they all have a look. They have a certain look and this Lex does not look like any of them, at least in the beginning, because he does clean himself up.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: So, I’m just wondering, where did they get this look from and what was that about? And, and was it because he was in prison, and he was trying to look like a certain group?
Perry Constantine: Yeah. I feel like it was just kind of like a, it was just kind of like a reflection of what he’d been through in like the, you know what, I think he says 17 years he was in prison.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes.
Perry Constantine: I think that was because, you know, we see the flashbacks of him in in season four, and he is got the full head of hair, which I thought was a definite choice.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes.
Perry Constantine: Now, and, and I know a lot of fans have like, you know, quibbled about this, but I actually like the idea of a ball of a bald, bearded Lex Luthor. I like the idea of him having the beard and everything. So, I thought John Crier, you know, I, I had some issues with John Crier’s overall performance, but I think his overall look like the shaved head and the beard was a, and you know, for anyone who can’t see me on this, but I’m a balded, I’m a bald bearded guy myself, so there’s probably some bias coming through there.
But
Y. M. Nelson: all of our Spotify fans.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. So, I, I like that. I like that. I like that kinda look that, you know, we first saw it, John Crier, I think was the first one to do it. If you saw the last season of Titans, there was Titus Welliver played Lex Luthor in like one episode. I. And he killed it. He was, he did such an amazing job in that, in that part.
But he also had the bearded look. He had a shaved head and he had a much bushier beard, like his b- beard was like, and then they had, they showed the first images of Michael Cudlitz with, you know, the shaved head and the, the kind of like, I didn’t like the idea of like this long goatee thing. I thought that was kind of a,
Y. M. Nelson: I, I didn’t like that either.
Yeah.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. And I, I definitely didn’t like the wig they gave him or whatever.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. I was like, what are they, the flashbacks? Why are they showing us that? Yeah. They didn’t even need to show us that.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: That was like a moment. Oh gosh. That, that was a moment. But also, yeah. Didn’t they?
Perry Constantine: But I thought they did such a great job of introducing him at the end of season three.
And, you know, he came in as just like this powerful presence and then he, you know, he unleashes Doomsday and we get that amazing ending of season three. Like the, the Rocky, the Rocky freeze frame ending, right? When they’re him, a Doomsday charging at each other in the moon.
Y. M. Nelson: Exactly.
It’s like, oh gosh.
Perry Constantine: And then I, I was so, I was so psyched for this season to see what we were gonna go with it. And I mean, Cudlitz is okay. I think he’s a really, I think he’s a really good actor, I think. But I feel like the, I’m not a big fan of this take on, on Luthor. I think he’s just too single-minded, whereas I’m thinking, you know.
Some of the more nuanced portrayals like Michael Rosenbaum on Smallville or John Shaa, even on Lois and Clark, or even though he got a little bit soapy at times, but I thought overall he did a pretty decent job as Lex Luthor or like I mentioned, Titus Weller on Titans or even, you know, Clancy Brown and Superman, the animated series.
And I feel like this version of Lex, I think they tried, I think they were leaning a little bit, too. Separating from Gene Hackman is a good thing. ’cause I think the Gene Hackman interpretation is kind of loomed over a little bit too large and like the the Superman Returns version with Kevin Spacey, or also, you know, what John Crier was doing in the Arrowverse stuff.
Y. M. Nelson: Mm-hmm.
Perry Constantine: So, I’m glad we’re leaning away from the Hackman inspired take. But I think too, they, they kind of forgot what they, what they did so well with Bruno Manheim was like rooting the character in this humanity. They, they lost sight of that with Lex Luthor in this season, I feel.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. They even said.
You know, Lois even says that in one of the later episodes. She’s like, “why are you still coming after me?” When she gets frustrated or whatever before she actually goes to the jail with Bruno Manheim, when she’s like totally frustrated.
Because at that point. You know Lex’s daughter, who we see in one of the middle episodes is trying and we thought that, or at least I thought that she would be the grounding force, kind of like Bruno has his family, right?
Perry Constantine: Right.
Y. M. Nelson: And, and his neighborhood too. But definitely his family and definitely his wife. But I thought that Lex’s daughter was gonna do that because I thought that she was the reason, them not speaking because Lois put him in prison.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: I thought that them getting together and her being able to talk him down was going to work. And when everybody saw that it didn’t work, it was like, why are you trying to come after these? I mean, what is it? It was very obsessive and kind for me with his motorcycle club kinda look, you know, going on too with that obsessive kind of feel to it.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: It felt very not good. You know,
Perry Constantine: yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: There, there’s no way I could really say that , but it felt very white supremacist kind of feeling, and, very much that kind of vibe that happens in those kind of circles.
It’s like, why do you keep going after somebody when there’s morally- what are you, do- you know?
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: What’s going on? What’s the motivation? That was the thing.
Perry Constantine: Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: What was the motivation?
Perry Constantine: Especially because. Yeah, especially ’cause like, I mean he, ’cause he got back everything. He, he had the chance to get back.
The only thing that he’s still missing was, was his daughter from that. And I guess like they’re trying to, I think it would’ve worked so much better if-
and also, you should mention that Elizabeth Henstridge played played his daughter also named Elizabeth.
Y. M. Nelson: Right.
Perry Constantine: She was also on, Agents of Shield.
She played, Simmons on Agents of Shield, and she also directed a bunch of these episodes in season three and in season four.
Y. M. Nelson: Really? Wow.
Perry Constantine: In fact, the episode where, where she plays Elizabeth was directed by her. She directed that she directed herself in that episode, so
Y. M. Nelson: Oh wow.
Perry Constantine: So yeah, really, really cool to see like she was getting so much play.
Also, just another note Amy, Joe Johnson the, the Pink Ranger from Power Rangers, Kimberly, she directed some of the episodes of this series as well. I think in season two. She directed some episodes.
Y. M. Nelson: Oh my gosh.
Perry Constantine: And Michael Cudlitz also directed at least one episode here too.
Y. M. Nelson: Oh wow. He did. So that’s not surprise. It’s cool.
Perry Constantine: But yeah, so this, I mean, yeah, I think like if Elizabeth had rejected Lex, I think then his, his obsession. Like going too far, I think might’ve made more sense. Might’ve hit a little bit better.
If she ultimately, like if Lois and Clark are trying to say like, no, no, give him another chance and all this, and she’s just like, no, I’m not gonna give him another chance. I don’t want to.
Y. M. Nelson: Right.
Perry Constantine: I don’t, I don’t think he can be redeemed or anything like that. I think that would’ve landed a little bit better than her trying to give him another chance and him still saying like, “I’m still gonna do this stuff anyway.”
Y. M. Nelson: Right.
Perry Constantine: Because I feel like that s sapped a lot of the humanity outta him. ’cause at this point, like, okay, now you’ve gotten back everything you’ve lost, so what are we still doing here?
[00:10:20] Doomsday v. Superman
Y. M. Nelson: Right. Right. You know, and at that point he showed less humanity than the Doomsday character who’s looking at Lois and is like, I remember, remember Bizarro Lois, I remember our family.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: You know, it’s like, are you kidding me? I have no idea about the Doomsday character in the comic, but here it’s like, you know. You at, the end, at, at Doomsdays Doom. You know, you actually, you know, you kind of felt something, you know, you felt a little, it’s like, okay.
He, he realized, all right, it’s, it’s my time to, yeah. Just, just push me on into the sun. Mm-hmm. And that was, that’s another thing too, that’s another thing that I was, I was wondering, I was like, is, is. Superman really going to kill him, because that’s another thing about Superman. You like Superman doesn’t kill people, right?
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: You know, it’s like, oh my gosh, Superman is not- he’s too good. He’s not, gonna kill people, you know? He is not gonna kill him, and he’s especially not gonna kill, you know, somebody who was him in another, you know, in a Bizzarro world, you know?
But it was almost kind of like a mercy kind of thing.
Like he was like. I’m Doomsday, I’m no longer, yeah. The person, you know, that I’m, I’m something else and just push me into the sun kind of thing. It was like he was kind of giving him permission. I was like, oh my gosh.
Perry Constantine: Well, it was very similar to the, Peia’s death in that way, right?
Y. M. Nelson: Yes. Exactly, exactly. It was, it, it was a lot like that. Yes.
[00:12:01] A rushed ending
Perry Constantine: And now one of my quibbles with the Yeah, the, the, the “Death of Superman” aspect of it is, and I feel, I’m not sure if this was a, a result of the fact that this was the, this ended up being the final season, which wasn’t necessarily originally the plan, ’cause they had also introduced some other characters in here.
Like, Milton Fine, who was Brainiac in the comics.
Y. M. Nelson: Okay, yeah.
Perry Constantine: Was introduced here. And they had also. The, the, the producers had said that. They had actually plans for like a fifth sea- up to like a sixth season, I think. I think they had plans up to season six.
Y. M. Nelson: Oh, wow.
Perry Constantine: And they had Tom Kavanaugh comes in here not playing any of the characters. He played on the Arrowverse, but instead he’s playing G Gordon Godfrey, who’s a character in the comics who is working for DarkSide. And so, they were actually planning to eventually lead up to like a, a DarkSide thing in, in, in this show as well, which obviously,
so, I feel like this was all kind of truncated and they had to like, kind of like jam in both the death of Superman and the, the Lex Luthor stuff into this one season. And I feel like the death of Superman stuff got a little bit shafted because I don’t feel like they gave that story really kind of the room to breathe that it needed.
I mean, that last episode of season three was amazing. I was, I was on the edge of my seat when they, when they cut to credits at that, at that final scene. Yes. And then. I love the first episode of this season too. But it it’s basically like it’s what, three? Yeah, it’s like three episodes and then, then Clark is back and so, right.
That was, and there’s a whole thing in the comics right after the death of Superman, there’s the reign of the Superman where there are these four different Superman characters who each show up. Basically, claiming like the title of Superman.
And this is where we introduced, this is where we got introduced to Steel in the comics. This is where we got introduced to the more modern Superboy in the comics. And you also had two other ones, the Eradicator and the Cyborg Superman. And I think we had all the pieces to do that in this, in this season.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Yeah.
Perry Constantine: You had Steel, you had Superboy. Yeah. In the form of Jordan. You had the Eradicator stuff from, you know his, his brother in the first season. And then all you need, the other piece of that is the, the cyborg Superman aspect. So, I feel like they could have found a way to do like their own take of Reign of the Supermen, and I was a little bit disappointed that we didn’t go down that route or at least some version of it.
‘Cause I feel like as much as we’ve been do- we’ve done the Death of Superman so many times, that other side of it has almost never been done except for like once it was at, at a adapted in animated form. And I think that would’ve been interesting to, to see happen here.
But they just, they didn’t have the time, they didn’t have the budget either too. ’cause this, this season, like the budget got slashed.
Y. M. Nelson: Oh, okay. So that, that’s what it was about. I felt like it-
Perry Constantine: Well, that’s also why there, the focus is so much also on Lex Luthor, because on Lex. Lex, okay. The supporting cast, the, they got downgraded all from like main cast to like supporting to like guest stars.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.
Perry Constantine: So, they were give- and like, I think in the end their credits were actually, they got credited as like the main cast, but they didn’t appear as much as they did in previous episodes. Like Sarah’s basically gone in this season, we, we barely see anything of her.
Y. M. Nelson: And, then in the last couple, or, well, not the last couple, but the last, yeah.
She’s basically gone and then she actually you know, they talk about her going to university kind of thing. And I didn’t think we were gonna see her in that very last episode.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: But she, we, we did see her a little bit in that very last episode. Her sister, I don’t even. Yeah. Was she even there there?
Perry Constantine: I don’t think she was. I think that was a, a case of was it Morgan on Boy Meets World where she end up going up to her room for like five years.
Y. M. Nelson: Right, exactly.
Perry Constantine: Or Judy on Family Matters.
Y. M. Nelson: Right. Exactly. What but yeah, and it was another character too. I was like. What happened? Oh, you know, they built up the whole, you know, relationship with Natalie and Mateo, but we don’t see Mateo at all.
Perry Constantine: Yeah, that’s right. Natalie doesn’t really appear that much either in this season. Natalie, she was awesome.
Y. M. Nelson: Natalie, exactly.
Natalie’s like, and when you were talking about the Cyborg, now she’s not a cyborg, but she, you know, does have a suit so she could
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: They could have manifested her into a fourth kind of character, not a cyborg character, but into a fourth character. If that was, if that was what they were gonna do.
But you’re right, I felt you know, because I know about at least that particular comic, The Death of Superman comic, at least I know about that comic. But I don’t know exactly what happens in all of it.
So, from my perspective with the season, it felt like Lex was getting this much and the Death of Superman was getting this much and the whole thing with his heart and you know Lois’s dad sacrificing himself so that he could give Superman a heart. A: I, I like how that happened, but B: I also didn’t like how that happened ’cause I was like, are they trying to just kill him off so we don’t have to see him anymore? What was going on with that? And two?
Perry Constantine: Yeah, that was a human, I think that was a result of the. Yeah. Yeah. I think that was a result of the cast cutting ’cause officially or originally, he had said that he wasn’t gonna be coming back, Dylan Walsh. And then later it was revealed that he was gonna be coming back in this in this one episode. So
Y. M. Nelson: yeah. Okay.
Perry Constantine: Or two episodes. Yeah. So
Y. M. Nelson: yeah, it’s two.
Perry Constantine: So yeah. So. Everyone had got cut down due to budget cuts and were, but they were all given the option to come back as a guest star. So that’s why all the supporting cast gets downgraded in this story. Michael Cudlitz was a main cast member in this, so he, that’s why he is, is such a large presence throughout this whole season, which yeah.
I feel like they should have found a better way to do that ’cause I feel like we got too much Luthor, basically, which is, it’s funny, it’s the contrast where like it was in, in Titans where I was saying, we only, we didn’t get enough here. We got too much of him.
Y. M. Nelson: Right. We got too much of him here. Yes. Yeah. Way too much.
Especially when he gets that obsessiveness because
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: By that point it gets old. Right. You know? Yeah. The most entertaining part is, you know, and of course I’ve already talked about this, but most entertaining part is when Lois goes to Bruno Manheim in the jail. That’s, that’s like some of the most entertaining stuff at that point.
After he gets obsessive after, after his daughter goes away, after the fight with him and Clark. And you and all of that. It, it’s just like, it just becomes obsessive.
And actually too, it kind of loses the plot a little bit. Because at, at one point he was trying to infiltrate the whole town.
Right. It it,
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: It was about Lois. Yes. But he also had kind of a plan going on and they kept talking about between him and, and the, I think her name is Amanda. Is that her character? Yeah.
Perry Constantine: Amanda McCoy. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: Okay. Yeah. ’cause you know, I just remember her, her actual name ’cause it’s the same as mine.
And they were talking about this plan we were starting to see it. It was starting to come together, and then he goes off the rails. So, we don’t really necessarily see the plan manifest because he’s just becoming obsessed. But then Amanda, you know, she has a plan going on, but I don’t understand what her motivation was either. Like what was actually. What actually were they trying to do?
You know, with Bruno Manheim and that whole story, we knew what he was actually trying to do. We knew his plan, and so everything that happens. And the whole meeting between Pia and, and Lois and they just happened to be in this hospital and all of that, it kind of comes together and it’s like a puzzle coming together.
And this is the nerdy part of me. I need that. If you’re gonna talk about a plan and you’re gonna talk about a puzzle or something coming together. We need to see that happen. Not,
Perry Constantine: yeah,
Y. M. Nelson: that it just totally breaks down and then you become obsessed. That is a letdown for me. You know, and that’s where I think the Luthor character kinda lets me down, right?
Perry Constantine: Yes. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: That’s where the,
Perry Constantine: I feel like he should have had the, the revenge is all fine and well, but I think he should, he needed to have something else pushing him for this, and he didn’t. And I think that was a, and you know, we had.
Also too, you go back to season one, you had Morgan Edge, Roe, like he had an actual plan, he had something he was working towards building towards.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes, yes.
Perry Constantine: And that’s the kind of, or, or Bruno as well, right? You had, he had this whole big scheme. He’s trying to work, he’s got reasons for what he’s doing and it’s like, that is Lex Luthor’s thing.
He is, you know, this master planner, he is this, he’s this great strategist. He, and they just, they, they shortchanged him. With that and just focusing by making this such a single-minded focus on, on revenge.
Y. M. Nelson: Exactly. Because I mean, even, even I know that, you know, Lex Luthor’s supposed to be like a genius, right?
It’s supposed stuff is supposed to, you know, it’s supposed to come together in some kind of master plan. He’s not just gonna be this, this focus of I’ve got to destroy Lois in any way possible, that doesn’t jive with the, the Lex that I know. And then, you know, also at the end to have the Brain Character
Perry Constantine: Brainiac?
Y. M. Nelson: Yes. But what was his actual, because they,
Perry Constantine: Milton Fine
Y. M. Nelson: call him Brainiac. Yeah. Milton Fine. So, to have him come in to be the brains per se. Right. And, he’s like, you know. Make me this suit. Isn’t there a point somewhere in the comic, or maybe it’s just something I’ve watched at some point where Lex Luthor does get some kind of suit or does get some kind of enhancement?
Yeah.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. He’s, you know, very famous images like this green power suit. Yeah, no, that’s what I kind of annoyed me. ’cause you see like the, the heads-up display, it’s got like the green and purple color scheme, but they didn’t even, so I’m like. This is such a key aspect of the character, why aren’t you just going to paint the suit green like you do in all the other version?
See, that was a, that was, that was another disappointment. However, though that that fight between Clark and, and Lex outside the hotel when he reveals like the red, the the red sunlight LA- lamps and they have to have a physical con- I thought that was, that was awesome. That was really good.
Y. M. Nelson: That was, that was awesome. It is the kind same kind of feeling that you got with Emmett a little bit. That, that was awesome. He shouldn’t be Superman because of the, because of the red lamps. Right. So, he was just Clark and he was just like, listen, don’t f with my family. Yo, don’t f with my town. You know?
He was, yeah. And it was just, all out and yes, I loved it. I loved it too. I mean, yeah, that was, that was totally awesome. That fight.
[00:23:37] The Clark Kent reveal to the world
Perry Constantine: Now we also get the, episode seven, regular guy. So, this is something they do, is they reveal, Clark reveals he’s Superman to the world.
Mm-hmm. So, before I start talking about this, I was curious, what did you think of, of that whole aspect of it?
Y. M. Nelson: He’s kind of forced a little bit to do it, and he has the family part, right. That, that dynamic, I’ve never really seen that dynamic. I’ve seen him having to deal with it himself, but now that he has kids who have superpowers, and they wanna be on Instagram or whatever, or they just wanna be kids, and they’re like, “I don’t understand, Dad, why you have to, hide this so much?”
Seeing that whole part of it and them do that dynamic with the whole, now I need to reveal that I’m Clark Kent, I’m also Superman, kind of thing, that layer was a really neat layer to see that I have never seen before.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: So, I kind of like how they did that. I’m not sure how I feel in general. Although, I will say this, I like them going back to The Daily Planet and, seeing Jimmy,
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: Olson, you know, be not as obnoxious as he normally is and other things.
And, and then wasn’t that his sister Janet Olson?
Perry Constantine: Yeah. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, I mean that was, that was neat. But I think the whole, we’re going to interview you in your home and, and those kinds of things that, that’s how we’re going to do it. I’m not sure how I feel about it, but I will say that it’s probably the most modern way we’ve seen him come out.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: What did you think?
Perry Constantine: It was? It was I’m mixed on it. I’m not sure when the episode’s gonna come out, especially in relation to this, but I was recently on my friend’s Superman podcast Digging for Kryptonite, and we talked about this episode and like the, the idea of like the Clark Kent secret identity and all that.
And I think it’s a very valuable thing to the character. And I feel like when you, you do kind of lose something when you take that away. And they, they’d done this twice in the comics fairly recently. It happened twice, actually.
Y. M. Nelson: Wow.
Perry Constantine: Yeah, the, the first time it happened is it was like this kinda like reboot type thing that I, that I mentioned before where his, his identity gets outed.
And he’s not married or anything like that, but he still has to deal with it and he ends up also getting de powered as well. So, it led to a really interesting story. I thought it did a really cool job.
But then this other story they did, they, they had gotten rid of that, they’d kind of done like a soft kind of reboot type thing, and then the writer who came on a little bit after that also did a story where Clark Kent decides that lying about his secret identity, lying about the fact that he’s Superman is a, the writer had this bizarre thing that like, well that’s how can the character be for truth and justice if he’s always lying about who he is?
I’m like, that’s, no, I think that makes it interesting. But but he did this story where Clark reveals to the world that he’s Superman. And it was just, it was just bad. It was badly done because, and they had to like do this thing where the, and, but here’s the thinker. He, he was still gonna keep his job at The Daily Planet as a reporter.
And so, they had to do this thing where, okay, so his parents’ house gets like this force field technology around it. The daily planet gets this. I’m just like, no, this is just, this sounds like what a little kid’s idea of what this stuff will be like. It’s like, well, we’ll just put a force field around it.
But I thought that it handled it in a pretty interesting way. I thought it was ’cause this is a world where, first off, you’re in the last season. Okay. So, you know, there’s not gonna be any further anything else going on here.
Y. M. Nelson: Right.
Perry Constantine: And we do have this thing at the end where he talks about how they set up this foundation, everything.
So, he’s not, it’s not like he’s going to work at The Daily Planet or anything like that, so.
Y. M. Nelson: Right.
Perry Constantine: I think if you’re gonna, if you’re gonna do a story where Clark reveals that he’s Superman and he’s not gonna be working, try still trying to be Clark Kent and working at the Daily Planet and all that.
That makes more sense. I can kind of jive with that a little bit. That said, I think would’ve been more interesting is what I thought they were leading to because like when they go to a manning the, the farm, right. Luthor’s trying to purchase all this land.
Y. M. Nelson: Mm-hmm.
Perry Constantine: So, he can build his new headquarters
Y. M. Nelson: mm-hmm.
Perry Constantine: And she refuses it. Right? They, everyone refuses the $10 million.
Y. M. Nelson: Right.
Perry Constantine: And then they go and, and they go to talk to her and they’re like, that’s a lot of money. You turn down. And she’s like, it’s nothing compared to what you’ve done for us. And, and I thought what they were gonna do is this whole idea is like, did you, did you watch Buffy?
Y. M. Nelson: Yes. Yeah,
Perry Constantine: I’m saying remember the end of the third season when they ha they’re at the prom and they’re giving out the class awards and they give Buffy the award of class protector and they’re like, Dale’s not like normal high schools. We know there’s weird
s–t that happens here.
We know and
Y. M. Nelson: yeah, exactly.
Perry Constantine: You have been there protecting us, like, and this whole thing is like, it’s been this open secret about Buffy this whole time. And so, I think I would’ve liked the idea if that’s what it was like in Smallville. I think that would’ve also reflected like a more accurate version of like a small-town dynamic where it’s like, yeah, we know, but we’re not gonna tell anyone about it.
Right? This is our town secret type of thing. I think that would’ve been a far more interesting dynamic to play with than what they did.
Y. M. Nelson: I agree. And it would’ve kept the whole realness that they had built up in season three because everybody, well, if you haven’t lived in a small town, you don’t know, but I have, I grew up in a small town and my mom complains all the time about running into people that she,
Perry Constantine: yeah, no, I, I, I lived in a small town for five years and I was, yeah.
And I was the only foreigner in this small town, so like everybody in town knew me. Oh. So, they know like every time. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. It’s like they knew you and they knew where you were and where you were. It’s like, oh, you were at blah, blah, blah, blah yesterday and we were looking for you. Exactly. It’s like there’s no way, I mean, this big of a secret, especially, you know, it’s gotta be one day in Smallville that
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: Clark breaks his glasses. You know, it’s like that has to have happened at some point.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: So, you know but yeah. Yeah. So yeah, I’m not, I thought I thought that that was gonna happen too, but it didn’t exactly happen, you know, it didn’t exactly happen like that.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. You know, so, I mean, it was a- I don’t agree with why they did it or kind of like the, the circumstances surrounding the reveal, but I thought that actual episode
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.
Perry Constantine: Was really well done and you know, yes. Up until the end where he, he just, you know, he opened, but I think would’ve been, and my, my my buddy mentioned this on our, on his show is I think would’ve been in more interesting is if instead of Clark opening his, his shirt and revealing he’s superman to, to the rest of the diner is if everybody in the diner just kind of stands up and just like blocks.
Him, you know, kind of like in Spider-Man Two. Yeah. Or if, if he, like he revealed he’s Superman and then, you know, Emmett’s like, look, he’s Superman, he’s, and everyone was like, what are you talking about?
Y. M. Nelson: Right. Oh my gosh, that would’ve been cool. You’re right.
Perry Constantine: That would’ve been been, I think that would’ve been so much better.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Would’ve been so, exactly. That would’ve been so much better,
Perry Constantine: Especially because we’re so close to the end. This happens in episode seven, and then we have three episodes left and they don’t really do anything with the i- with the, the fact the identity is completely public now, so it, it all just kind of felt like you’re, if you’re gonna do this, you have to really commit to it.
And I don’t feel like they had enough space to really commit to that idea. So. Yeah, it was a little bit of a letdown, all in all. But I, but that, that episode though, was one of my favorites of the season. So, it’s,
Y. M. Nelson: yeah,
Perry Constantine: great episode. Really well done the way they did it. But I think there were better or different ways they could have done it.
That would’ve been more interesting.
[00:31:23] Kids with superpowers
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Yeah. You know, for me the, the highlight of it was. Or the highlight of, of that whole thing was the, the dynamic between the kids, because of course the kids have superpowers and, and how, how do they deal with that? But they also kind of let that down, too.
It’s like the kids just, you know, it’s like by, by episode. The end, the last episode, or either episode nine or the last, or whatever the last episode is, or the, the episode before that. It’s just, they just get mobbed everywhere, you know? Mm-hmm. And that’s how they’re dealing with it. They get mobbed everywhere.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. And that’s something else. I had an issue. Well also too, when we get to the last episode and we find out that, you know, they’ve gotten married and they’ve had kids of their own. So, it’s like, well, how did they deal with that dynamic then? Right, right. ’cause now that, so I feel like that was all very- yeah, that was kind of a letdown.
I, I didn’t feel like they had really, they, I don’t think they had really thought through like all the ramifications of what revealing this secret identity is. It’s one thing if it’s just Superman and Lois, but when they have two teenage kids around who have superpowers as well and they have to deal with it, too.
And I feel like that’s, there’s a lot of questions that are left unanswered that need to be answered.
Y. M. Nelson: Right. And but, but at the same time, I think that they would need. At least a half of another season to do that and really do it well, especially to get to the point where they had gotten in the epilogue season, epilogue episode.
Right. You know, because Jonathan is already having issues with his girlfriend after, you know, and you know, they’re, you know, mobbing her on social media and stuff. That could have been like a whole thing with them, you know? Yeah. So, I just think that they didn’t have. Time, but they wanted to show them in a good place and they wanted to show kind of a continuity thing, which is what people think that continuity thing is, means happily ever after.
Perry Constantine: Yeah, they yada yada a lot of stuff to get to the end, to get to the happy ending there. And I feel like
Y. M. Nelson: Exactly,
Perry Constantine: and I think that they wouldn’t have had these questions wouldn’t have even been a problem if it was just, you know, like I said, that if it was just this idea that it’s an open secret in the town, and that would’ve been it.
Y. M. Nelson: Right, right. That would’ve been cool because you know, because with that, like you were saying with that Buffy episode, they said, okay, we know what’s going on, blah, blah, blah. And then there are like at least- was it three more seasons or two more? More season?
Perry Constantine: Oh God, no. It was, it was,
Y. M. Nelson: there was a lot more season.
Perry Constantine: More season. It went up season seven. Yeah. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: Okay. Four more seasons where she’s still, you know, fighting and everything. So, the dynamic in the town would not be everywhere that Jordan and Jonathan go, that they’re mobbed, you know? Yeah, yeah. Or, or something like that. You know? I don’t know.
It, it is just, it, I just feel like it would be different, especially with a small town. There would be a lot more, especially like quips, I think
Perry Constantine: like that
Y. M. Nelson: that would’ve been cool like that,
Perry Constantine: like that. Like the, well, like the store scene, right? When the, right when that girl, Denise, she looks up at the TV and she at the plane crash, and then she kind of looks at Clark and she looks back, she’s like, are you gonna go?
He’s, he’s like, oh, I forgot my wallet. And then he comes, and she’s like, you’re back. All right.
He’s like, oh, I just ran out to the car.
And she’s like. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. We go, we’ll go with that.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, that’s right. Right. Exactly. It would’ve been cool to have a lot more of those scenes, you know?
Perry Constantine: Exactly. I think it would’ve been, or you know, it would also have been a lot more fun too.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, exactly.
Perry Constantine: It would’ve been a lot more interesting.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, right. But yeah.
[00:35:09] Where is Superman and Lois in the Arrowverse?
Y. M. Nelson: So, we talked a lot about these seasons, but they are two very packed seasons. But we definitely wanna talk about the last episode.
Right before we do though Perry, you did mention that there was some, and I try not to, you know, look at any of the behind the scenes or you know, any of that kind of stuff, shakeups.
So, you know, one of the things that I was, but because I’ve been a fan of a lot of these CW shows, one of the things that kind of is in the back of my mind, especially for Superman and Lois, was kinda how this all fits in, but I guess what I guess from what I’m hearing is that all of these shows, I don’t think any of them are still on.
Right? Is Star Girl still on?
Perry Constantine: No. No. I’m pretty sure that’s gone, too. I think they’re all, this was, I’m pretty sure this was the last one.
Y. M. Nelson: Okay. So, a, from a fan standpoint, how does Superman and Lois fit in with the, the Arrow verse? They’re from a different, they’re from a different universe than Arrow was and Flash, right?
Arrow, Flash, and Bat Woman are in a different.
Perry Constantine: Right. So originally it was so originally Arrow Flash, and, Batwoman and Legends of Tomorrow, Originally, they were all from the same universe.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.
Perry Constantine: And Super Girl and Black Lightning were originally from separate universes, but then in the, they did the Crisis of Infinite Earths.
They brought ’em all into the same universe in that part.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes.
Perry Constantine: And honestly, I think they, they should have ended it there, but they all just kind of like puttered out after that. Now, the original plan of Superman and Lois, I believe the original plan was that it was supposed to be part of that.
New universe as well because the end of Crisis, Superman is flying back and he talks to Lois and he, and she says, your sons are waiting for you. Whereas in Crisis, it would reveal they had one baby, but now it’s like they have, they have two sons, so
Y. M. Nelson: Right.
Perry Constantine: So that was like, kinda like there was gonna be like a reset and they were gonna have two sons then in that series and that was gonna continue on there.
And there was originally a plan for them to do a crossover episode with Batwoman. But it was canceled because of COVID restrictions. So, oh, in the first season. So, they’d never done the crossover episode. And then by the time they got to season two, the other shows had kind of much, pretty much fizzled.
And even remember, if you may remember, they, they had Diggle appear in season one as well,
Y. M. Nelson: Right! Yes. Yeah.
Perry Constantine: So, by the time they get to season two though, all the other shows had gone. So, then there is. There’s just this one throwaway line that Sam mentioned to the boys at the end of season two, where he says, like, we’ve seen other worlds where there are other heroes, but on our world, it is only Superman.
So that kind of officially established that this is in its own separate continuity. And then they could go in and they could use their own Jimmy Olson, they could use their own Lex Luthor, which, which is what they did here. And they have, you know, they brought Tom Kavanaugh playing a completely different character then as well.
So, yeah, as of season two, this was officially a separate universe, whereas in season one it was kind of unsure. Like some people were saying maybe it is. Some people were saying maybe it was, maybe it isn’t. So okay. It wasn’t quite clear at first, but by season two it was clear that we don’t have to tie it into Arrow anymore.
’cause all the Euro stuff, all the Arrowverse stuff is gone. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: Which is interesting how that all played out. And I guess it was, you know, studio issues and studio problems because at the end of, I think that was Crisis of Infinite Earths, wasn’t it? Where they all got together in that warehouse like thing and mm-hmm.
They were all trying to be, were they trying to be like a Justice League kinda thing there or something?
Perry Constantine: Yeah, that was the implication, but then nothing was ever done with it.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, it was, I was like, oh my gosh, what? You’re trying to be a a Justice League thing and Arrow is not even here anymore. So, you got this one empty chair and then the rest of the shows. Well, Flash was kind of on its way out at that point. It had like what last? I think two seasons left after that.
Perry Constantine: Two or th I think it, I think it went on for like a- I think it was maybe three more seasons. Might have been. I think so, yeah. ’cause yeah, about three more seasons I think came after that.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.
Perry Constantine: ’cause it was, I think it was in its, I can’t remember if it’s last season, it was still running concurrently with Superman and Lois. Superman and Lois was running kind of concurrently with Flash, and I want to say some others were still running at the same time. So, there was still some, there’s some crossover.
But they were all on their way out. And I think by season two of Superman and Lois, it was the only, it was the last man standing.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, so we’re just gonna take Superman and Lois as its own thing that started in the Arrowverse, but it’s its own thing, which I kind of like that because I think Arrow because now that era, the Arrowverse era is kind of done. Yeah. I like that. This is, it’s in its own bubble because it is really special to me.
[00:40:25] The Last Episode
Y. M. Nelson: And with that, let’s talk about the last episode and let’s give this thing a rating and wrap this, or these episodes, which it’ll probably be.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: So, what did you think of the last episode and how they wrapped up this series?
Perry Constantine: I mean, I thought the, the resolution to the, the Doomsday and Lex stuff was kind of rushed. ’cause I think feel like they really kind of wanted to get that outta the way. And then it, it felt very similar to the Supergirl finale in that way too, where they kind of like rushed through the, the final and then they just focus on the end after that.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.
Perry Constantine: So, like, and I feel like this episode should have been a little bit longer. Right? I feel like it was a little bit, I feel like they, they should have made it like a double sized episode or something.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes.
Perry Constantine: To give a little bit more space to breathe. That’s exactly what I thought. Overall, I, I really liked it.
Right? ’cause they had bookended it. Right? Because you start off with the first episode with Clark narrating and telling his story about how he got to Metropolis and how he married Lois. And then they had, they had the kids and all that.
And then they, they move into the story and then it, it bookends it here with, with him also narrating the end of his life story. And I thought it was very well done. I liked it. It was, it was, it was definitely overly sappy. But I definitely ate it up. I thought it did a really cool job.
They bring in they bring in Krypto at the end too. I thought that was a nice little touch.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes.
Perry Constantine: This idea of him having this like foundation that they’re doing to go to help people we get to see the, the super team, basically, right? You see John and Jordan get their suits. We see Steele gets a more comic accurate suit in the end.
He gets the cape finally, finally, after all these years and, and and after the, the, the Shaq movie that we’re not gonna talk about,
Y. M. Nelson: please don’t,
Perry Constantine: he finally gets the cape. So yeah, I, I really dug it. I, I thought most of that was pretty well done, and the ending when he, he’s going through and he, and he dies and you know, I think a lot of people misunderstood that, that whole like afterlife sequence. ’cause a lot of people were saying like, well why are the boys there? And all this, I, my, my way of looking at that was, that was Clark kind of like in his, that was like his life flashing before his eyes type of thing.
Y. M. Nelson: That’s what I thought. What, what are other people That’s, that’s way I that saying.
Perry Constantine: I remember, I remember at the time people saying like, wait, how come Jordan and Jonathan are there? How come they’re dead? And I’m like, I’m like, no, no, they’re not. So, I thought it was trying to say that this is what can,
Y. M. Nelson: and they’re, but we already saw, we saw them.
See, this is, yeah. I thought it was, we saw them as adults by his bedside when he died.
Perry Constantine: Exactly.
Y. M. Nelson: So, when we see them again, they’re kids. It’s his life flashing before his eyes. Or he’s reliving That’s what I flashing. Okay. He’s reliving the good times.
But I also thought too that it was, you know how like at the end of a lot of series,
Perry Constantine: it was like the cast bow type of thing. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. The cast goes around And that’s what I thought it was too.
Perry Constantine: That too. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: I thought it was that.
Perry Constantine: But also too, like, and I remember some people, some people were also questioning about the Lex thing when he sees Lex there at the table. And like my, my whole feeling was like that was him letting go of any lingering resentment or hatred he had for Lex Luthor in that he was dying.
That that’s the way I, I looked at all that. And then the final scene that is him reuniting with Lois in the afterlife that that’s how I took all of that. Like once he walks through that door’s,
Y. M. Nelson: exactly what
Perry Constantine: we’re afterlife took.
Y. M. Nelson: That’s what I thought too.
Yeah.
Perry Constantine: Now one thing I will say, like, because it was called
Superman and Lois,
I do kind of wish that when he stepped out of the door, he was in the Superman suit, so that we had kind of had like that closing image of Superman and Lois together.
But that’s smoke quibble.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. I, no, I, I agree with that because the thing is, he’s seeing her at basically when she’s like a superhero in his eyes, right?
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: Because we had already had this story that, that’s what I was talking about earlier. He, we had already had this story about her in that red dress.
Perry Constantine: Right.
Y. M. Nelson: And he just thought that she was just beyond when she was in that red dress. So, he should have had his Superman suit on. I agree.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: I agree.
Perry Constantine: Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: So, they could just, you know, be in that moment, you know? I can’t believe people didn’t understand.
Perry Constantine: Well, it’s like, it, I mean, it goes back. You have this type of thing, like people talk about.
Again, Superman. The movie, when they talk about how, well, how does flying around the world, backward turning the world, reversing the reverse rotation? I’m like, no, he’s not actually reversing the rotation. That’s visualizing him flying back in time.
Y. M. Nelson: Right. Exactly. Oh my gosh. Well, yeah. Okay. So, people just wanna have something to argue about. That’s pretty much what it is.
Perry Constantine: Media literacy is dead, is basically what I think it is.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, exactly. But I thought that the, the moment that he had with Lex was powerful, to be honest.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: Because he does. Forgive Lex, but if you notice, I don’t think Lex forgives himself. And that was kind of what he was saying as he was kind of narrating it.
That was kind of what I, or at least what I was getting from it, was that some people can’t forgive themselves or can’t get out of that loop. And
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: I’m thinking, you know, he’s probably, or he’s trying to say that maybe even in death, Lex could not get out of that loop, you know? Yeah. Of what, you know, evilness that he was in.
But for me, I. Agree. I thought that the first part, the Doomsday part was rushed, and I thought it was just because they wanted to get Doomsday outta the way, and that was the only way.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: That they could do it. That made any kind of sense, because by this point, Doomsday is like unbeatable, you know?
He’s like,
Perry Constantine: yeah, yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: It’s like, how are you gonna actually kill this thing? So that was kind of rushed.
And then the part where they kind of get together in the town so that they can knock him out or whatever. I was like, okay, so we’re just getting the big, the heavy hitter players that have been here all four seasons.
We’re giving them another cameo.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. So that’s kind of how I felt about that because I’m like, what happened to the whole town? But then, but then it’s also like we were just saying about how they did after, you know, they say Clark Kent is Superman, how the town is reacting is, doesn’t make sense, but you know, ’cause I was like, where’s the rest of the town?
It would’ve been cool if the town had actually got together because the town, pretty much, or everybody that was awake at the time when Doomsday came back with Superman’s body, they were all
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: Looking at him. So, it would’ve been like, yeah, wouldn’t it been interesting to have the town come together and kill this thing, you know?
But whatever. But yeah, I thought that was, I thought that was a, a little rushed. I do like the end obviously from a romance standpoint, that very end where he opens door and he sees Lois and it’s taking me back to the season three and it’s taking me back to how he sees her and how he adores her.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: That really just got me. Right?
Perry Constantine: Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: I was like,
Perry Constantine: yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: This is like- Superman fans who are not also romance author fans are gonna be like, Aw. But I am like, oh, this is cute. I’m like, I, I was, I was having a moment. I, I was like, yeah, we were almost crying there. It was just totally cute. I, I love the way that, that, that ended.
I, I will say something I didn’t like, though. That may have just been me and that may have just been kinda where I am in everything, but the whole you know, his boys grow up and have all of these kids all over the place and everything. I know that was supposed to be kind of, continuity kind of happily ever after kind of thing.
They do it in, in romance novels often. Mm-hmm. The happily ever after is showing the couple, not just married, but the couple having a family and then
Perry Constantine: Right.
Y. M. Nelson: Sometimes they even make another generation Right. To, to show that. But you know. That didn’t really do anything for me necessarily. It’s good to see them grow up or whatever, but I didn’t really need that and I didn’t really need all those kids running around.
But the other thing that bothered me about it was there’s no way I’m gonna know if these kids had superpowers, which ones had superpowers, which ones didn’t? How do we know. You know, there, there’s all these other little questions that come up when we’re talking about family and we, we kind of touched on
Perry Constantine: Well, yeah, the thing I was wondering is
Y. M. Nelson: we touched on those too.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. Are we still operating as superheroes? Like what, what whole situation? Like, and so those are questions that we’re, I mean, Clark we can understand, we can kind of accept that, that he’s probably retired now and that he probably hands it over to the boys at some point.
So, I feel like that’s why I think they should have fit the open secret thing. ’cause that would’ve made this thing make a little bit more sense, then you can kind of imagine how it can still-
I also was wondering, was Jordan’s wife Sarah or not? Because she looks like, I don’t know what Jordan, which one wasn’t tell, but that
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, you can’t,
Perry Constantine: don’t mention,
Y. M. Nelson: you can’t tell which one is
Perry Constantine: these women are, and it’s like you,
Y. M. Nelson: right.
Perry Constantine: You need to get, it would’ve been nice to have sort of closure about relationship too.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes, exactly. Because I feel like for me, I feel like. Jordan and Sarah are really soulmates. They’re, they’re just going through some teenage stuff right now.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: But if they were in a romance novel, they’d be a second chance romance, and they would get back together when they were adults and they understood each other.
Perry Constantine: And she could still travel the world because he’s, you know, he, he’s, he could anywhere in the world in a matter of minutes. So, it’s not a, that’s not a, it’s not a barrier to their relationship.
Y. M. Nelson: Exactly.
Perry Constantine: So yeah, I feel like they should have given us some closure with that relationship, which I guess that scene at the the wedding was supposed to do.
Yeah. When she talks about how, you know, she, she still wants to be, she doesn’t wanna come back to Smallville, but it still felt like they weren’t. Really putting the button on that.
Also, I, I like that we got to see Lana and, and John Henry get married too.
Y. M. Nelson: Yes.
Perry Constantine: Love that aspect of it.
Y. M. Nelson: I, I did. I love that too.
Perry Constantine: Although Lois’s offic-.
Y. M. Nelson: No,
Perry Constantine: I did feel like Lois’s speech at the wedding, I felt like. Dude, this is not you. Hey, you should only be talking about that, not talking about your life.
Y. M. Nelson: Right, exactly. I’m like, Uh uh this, this ain’t your moment. This is their moment.
Perry Constantine: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: You’re gonna add your moment.
This is their moment.
Perry Constantine: But I will also say like, Kyle ended up being one of the most in having one of the most interesting character arcs over the whole series. ’cause I hated him. Yeah, when we first saw him in the first season, yeah. I’m like, guy’s, guy’s a piece of shit. I hope he could hope he dies at the end of this, but man, by the end, I’m like, man, I’m so for Kyle,
Y. M. Nelson: yes, I’m, I’m totally rooting for him.
I’m rooting for him and, and Miss Beppo, I can’t remember her first name.
Perry Constantine: I love for, and Chrissy, I love that line when she, when Kyle’s talking about how he wasn’t always the nicest and everything, and how he wasn’t very nice to. Still look when they first came to Don and then Christy’s like, did I get knocked up by?
Yeah. Yeah. Alright.
Y. M. Nelson: ‘Cause he was, he was, he was just a straight up, but he was yeah, I agree. I did not like him at the beginning and now I’m, you know, here rooting for him at the end and, and you know, so you, he had a really interesting character and I, and yeah, go ahead.
Perry Constantine: And I love that he, he was there when, when Clark collapsed on the street and he says like, you know, yes, right at the same spot where my dad collapsed, but because I had Kyle there, I was a, I didn’t die that day.
I’m like, oh, that, that, like, I, I love that moment. I love that moment there that it was Kyle who was there with him and that they, they, they stayed friends in Smallville after all this time. I thought that was beautiful. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. I mean the, the whole ending of this, yeah, it, it was sappy, but it was so good.
It was like nice syrupy pancakes. It was so, was so awesome.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: But I do agree with you that, you know, it should have taken the Star Trek feel. Should have had a two-hour finale.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: And that, yeah, that way that the first part didn’t feel as rushed as it did because you know, by this point, you know, Doomsday is the better villain.
Lex in, in my opinion. That’s just my opinion. And so, before we
Perry Constantine: No, no, I like, we, we got, like I said, we got too much Lex.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, exactly. So, I feel like we might have exhausted this, but do you have anything else that we didn’t talk about that you wanted to mention?
Perry Constantine: No, I mentioned everything that I wanted to, I wanted to say I mean overall like it’s, it, it was such a great show. Like it didn’t end, it, didn’t it? Unfortunately, the ending didn’t hit the highs that we got in in three, but, so I still think they stuck the landing more than anything else. Bit of a bumpy ride to get to the landing, but I still think they stuck the land.
[00:54:49] Goodreads rating
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Yeah, I agree. So, on a five-star rating we do the Good Reads rating here. As, as you know, and as our audience may remember, we use the Good Reads rating, ’cause this is really supposed to be a book podcast. But our rating one to five, one star is you didn’t like it, two stars. It was okay.
Three stars. You did like it. Four stars, you really liked it. And five stars. It was amazing. Now, you may wanna give some star ratings for the seasons that we talked about here, season three, season four. And you may wanna give a star rating for what you thought overall, or you just may want to give one or two of those, whatever.
What do you, what did you think star rating was? I.
Perry Constantine: So, season three, definite five. Okay. Yeah. Season three would be a definite five. Season four. Maybe 3.5, bordering on four. I I did like, even though, you know, the problems we’ve talked about aside, I still like season four a lot.
If I was gonna rank all these seasons in order, I would say season three, number one with a bullet, season one and season four, kind of even maybe season one a little bit more.
And then season two would be my least favorite of the seasons. And overall is a series let’s go with 4.5, I think overall for the series. Yeah. Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: My any any particular, well, you kinda already talked about the reasons why, but you wanna add on any, any reasons why?
Perry Constantine: I mean, it’s just the, the way that they had grounded, the family dynamic, the, you know, the, the performances, especially like Tyler Hoechlin and, and Bitsie Tulloch just, they just brought, they just brought it. Yeah. But even like the supporting forms, like this is my, this is my favorite take of on Lana Lang that we’ve ever seen. It’s, it’s yes, I loved Wole Park, Emmanuel Chiriqui.
I, I’m never sure how to pronounce her last name, but she did such a great job as Lana. I loved Wole Parks as, as John Henry Irons as Steel. The boys, like we talked about Natalie, and you know, like you said, you know, Kyle, like surprising how much I ended up liking Kyle by the end there. Exactly. And I thought, you know, I didn’t like the way that they had written him, but I still thought that Cudlitz did a pretty good job with what he was given, the material he was given.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.
Perry Constantine: Bruno Manheim like we talked about, and, and Peia and all them. So yeah. Overall wonderful performances. This is a great take on the, the Superman mythos and I, again, I, I feel like people are gonna, it’s funny ’cause now people are starting to take another look at Brandon Rouse’s Superman and they’re kind of talking about what a missed opportunity it was.
And I feel like people are gonna be doing the same thing with Tyler Hoechlin in a few years. They’re gonna be looking back at him and be like, oh my God, this is really good.
Y. M. Nelson: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I’m going to echo a lot of what you said. But I’m, I’m gonna kind of put a romance angle on it as well for, for my romance audience.
For season three, yes. Five stars plus for season three. For season four, I I’m gonna give the first half of it four stars, and I’m gonna give the second half of it three stars because I just think that the Lex plot, just drug it down.
Started off with some good stuff there, but when it, when the Lex stuff lost the whole plan and became obsessive, then it, it drug it down. Of course, the, the very end scene was a five star, you know, for me.
Perry Constantine: Mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: As a romance person. And for the whole series, I’m giving the whole series of 4.5. I really like this series. And I really wanted more of the series, unlike the other CW shows, which, like we said, we’re gonna just put this one in a bubble.
But the other CW shows I lost interest.
Perry Constantine: Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: In them.
I started out with, with Arrow, and I was all in it for about three seasons, and then I was, I was done. I, was out,
Perry Constantine: I stuck with,
Y. M. Nelson: and I tried, but I couldn’t.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. I stuck with Arrow and Flash until the end. ’cause Arrow went up until Crisis and then it, so I was still all in on re- most of the shows then.
So, I stuck with Arrow. And I stuck with The Flash the last two seasons that were such a slog to get through. They were, they were horrible to get through. Yes. And I, I did, I did manage to finish The Flash. Super girl. I got like four episodes into the final season. And I only watched the, and then I skipped to the finale, and I only did that because I was on another podcast talking about stuff that happened in that episode.
Y. M. Nelson: Oh, right.
Perry Constantine: And, and I was completely lost. Oh boy. And I never finished Legends or Black Lightning or Bat. I never even really got into Batwoman. I think I saw like only a few episodes the first season of Batwoman, and I just kind of tapped out. So, yeah. But Superman and Lois, I, I wanted, I definitely wanted more.
As disappointed, I am that the, it was truncated and this fourth season ended up being the last season. It, in a way, it, it’s kind of like going back to the Buffy analogy, it’s kinda like the way Angel did because Angel’s fourth season was, fifth season was not supposed to be its last season.
But then what they gave us in that last season was amazing and they gave us like the greatest series finale ever with that final, that final episode. Yes. So, yeah, I mean, quibbles aside, and I think maybe the quibbles that I have with season four show that it probably is a good thing that we didn’t get more.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.
Perry Constantine: But if they did have more of a budget, maybe we could have gotten something better, A better season four. So, it’s a, I think so. You’re always gonna be second guessing these things.
Y. M. Nelson: Right, right. I, I agree. I, you know, now that I, I know about the budget issues and things like that, it’s like if they had gone all out, they probably, we probably would’ve gotten a, a better season four.
I don’t think it would’ve been better than season three though. ’cause for me, especially as a romance author, and especially as someone who also likes dramatic, kinda relationship. I also write romantic women’s fiction, which is- the whole point of it is an emotional journey, so
Perry Constantine: Right.
Y. M. Nelson: You know, shows like This Is Us and A Million Little [Things]* and those kinds of shows. Those shows I gravitate towards, and season three, had that feel, it had the nerdy that I needed with the superhero stuff, but it also had the drama that I, that I needed, you know, without I you know, all the, all the crying from the, like with This Is Us constant crying and bawling.
So that’s why and that is why I liked this particular show above all the other CW shows is because this show has realness, has the authenticity, and it has that family dynamic that you’re not seeing in the other shows.
The other shows tend to either be like with Arrow for the time that I watched it, he was just kind of tortured. And so, it was kind of going downhill there. And he was just in torture.
With, with the Flash, which that was the one that I actually made it through all of it, but those last two seasons, and especially that last one, it was, it was a slog. They were going towards camp and
Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.
Y. M. Nelson: You know, a lot of these super, especially DC superheroes shows, or especially the live action ones, they tend to go to camp.
And camp is okay in the seventies, but in 2025, I kind of want a little bit more.
Perry Constantine: Yeah. You gotta, you gotta balance it out a little bit more.
Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Yeah. But yes, so that, that’s what I’m giving it. I’m giving it a 4.5. Overall. I agree. I think people slept on it.
And I think with the James Gunn Superman, which I hope to have you back to talk about that when that comes out.
Perry Constantine: I am probably gonna be talking about that thing nonstop. So, you’re probably going to be bored.
Y. M. Nelson: You probably are. You probably are. But I think, I think when that comes out, depending on how that goes, which I, I have high hopes that it’s going to bring a light onto, like you said, onto other Superman portrayals and maybe on down the line, this one will get get looked at again.
Perry Constantine: Yeah.
Y. M. Nelson: And, and get some eyes on it, which it needs some eyes on it, but yeah, I had a wonderful time with this.
I thank you for hanging on with me and talking about these seasons, because we’ve talked for a while. This is probably gonna end up being two episodes, but you know, I’ve gotta have you back.
Thunderbolts is already out in theaters, so I gotta have you back.
Perry Constantine: Have you seen it yet?
Y. M. Nelson: I have not seen it yet, but you know, I’m going.
Perry Constantine: It’s good.
Y. M. Nelson: Oh, yes. I, I, I have to. I have that on the docket. And of course, Superman again, you know? Mm-hmm. We got, we gotta talk James Gunn Superman.
So
Perry Constantine: Fantastic Four’s coming out this summer, too.
Y. M. Nelson: Exactly. So, I have that one as well.
So, you know, I’m gonna have you back, Perry, you know, I’ve gotta talk with you about all of this wonderful, nerdy superhero, goodness.
Perry Constantine: Always looking forward to it. Always a great time. Always love coming on here.
Y. M. Nelson: Hi, want to get show notes from this and future episodes in your inbox? Then subscribe to Nerdy Romantics Newsletter at Nerdy Romantics podcast.com/subscribe, nerdy romantics newsletter not only has show notes, but nerdy and romantic wrecks and sneak peeks and exclusives of my spice, nerdy romances and love, love stories.
I love talking sci fi, superheroes, fantasy, and romance books, movies, and shows with my friends. So, share this podcast with your nerdy romantic friends. Thanks for listening and for watching.
Want these show notes in your inbox?
Subscribe to Nerdy Romantics Newsletter
Discover more from Nerdy Romantics Podcast
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.









