Captain America: Brave New World review, part 2/2

While we’ve touched on some of the online controversy behind a show or a movie, we rarely delve into tat on the podcast. But because it seemed to swirl and hover over Captain America: Brave New World, we decided we need to address it. See what we say about that (and why it’s not worth talking about to real Marvel fans), the post-credits scene, and other characters. We also give this movie a star rating.

Have you listened to or seen part 1 of this review? click here for the beginning of our discussion.

Topics Discussed (Click to jump to transcript’s section) :

  • The Captain America: Brave New World Controversy
  • Casting Controversy
  • Characters we wanted more of
  • Post-Credits scene review and explanation
  •  Goodreads Rating

Some of our guest hosts:

Perry Constantine

Born and raised in the Chicagoland area, Percival Constantine grew up on a fairly consistent diet of superhero comics, action movies, video games, and TV shows. At the age of ten, he first began writing and has never really stopped.

Percival has been working in publishing since 2005 in various capacities–author, editor, formatter, letterer–and has written books, short stories, comics, and more. He has a Bachelor of Arts in English and Mass Media from Northeastern Illinois University and a Master of Arts in English and Screenwriting from Southern New Hampshire University.

Currently, Percival lives in southern Japan where he continues to work on new projects and also teaches literature, writing, and film.

Books/graphic novels mentioned on the podcast:

Want to contact him?

Website: https://percivalconstantine.com

Superhero Cinephiles – a podcast about superheroes in media hosted by Perry Constantine. Listen wherever you get your podcasts! https://superherocinephiles.com

Threads | Bluesky | Facebook | Instagram

Where to find books from the podcast:

Support Indie Bookstores by buying at Bookshop!
Click here

*The Bookshop.org link/image above is linked to a list of books reviewed on the podcast . By purchasing a book from there, you support independent book stores, and I will receive a small commission for each purchase when using these links. (This does not affect what you pay.)

Episode Available on
most podcast providers

TuneInApple PodcastsSpotifyGoogle PodcastsAmazon MusicStitcheriHeartRadioPodcast AddictPodchaserPocketCastsDeezerListen NotesPlayer.fmPodcast IndexCastroCastBoxPodfriend

Don’t have a podcast provider?
Listen to this episode here!

Watch the episode on YouTube


Episode Transcript

back to top

Y. M. Nelson: On this episode of Nerdy Romantics Podcast, we continue our discussion of Captain America Brave New World. We talk about Sam Wilson as the new Captain America, and all of the online controversy around this choice. We talk a little bit about a casting controversy that didn’t really have to happen. And we explain the post credit end scene and give our thoughts on the post credit end scene.

We finally wrap it all up with a Goodreads rating based on Goodreads’ one-to-five-star rating. Remember, there will be spoilers on this episode as well.

​

Y. M. Nelson: So, if you’ve watched Captain America, please

Stay tuned.

This is the Nerdy Romantics Podcast and I’m your host, YM Nelson.

back to top

[00:01:21] The Captain America: Brave New World Controversy

Y. M. Nelson: So now that we’ve mentioned it a couple of times, I usually don’t talk about controversy that goes on ’cause I rather talk about the piece itself, the movie or the book or the show, whatever we’re talking about.

But because there is so much controversy that’s going on with this let’s talk a little bit controversy.

Okay. Hands raised for everybody who thinks Black Captain America being controversial is something that we even need to talk about. Or is this pure junk?

Staci: I think it’s junk.

Perry Constantine: I mean it I think it’s junk.

Marcie: Very,

Perry Constantine: but think it’s worth talking about in to some degree. But yeah, it is junk. Yeah.

Staci: Yeah. I, it’s not controversial to me, but I’m not the person to find it controversial, so, I mean, to me, I think every time there’s something different, it’s like, why you have to change this or you know, we’ve all seen like what happened with Bridgerton and you know, stuff like that.

So, we know that certain people have an issue with it. You know, the ones that say this is not, and I think it is canon because I think there is, it is from the comic books, but

Perry Constantine: it is,

Staci: Yeah. But people will say, no, that’s not the Captain America. I saw it in the last three movies or whatever. How many movies when, okay, but this is not from the mo- they’re getting it from comic books.

Well, I mean, I don’t wanna go about what’s going on right now and the stuff that’s going on in the world and in this country. But yeah, I see that that might have been when they tested it with certain audiences, they were like, we might have to change some things.

So, I think it depends on the audience.

Marcie: I, I do think that. I think it, unfortunately, there was some timing of things that were coming, that were happening outside of it that did impact ’cause I bet if you ran that test screen now, I feel like, the response might have been different because everybody is sitting in a different place.

But I think, I do think that that’s part of it. I think that might also be the part that, in the way that the film was made irks me about the name because is the brave new world part that we got a Black Captain America? Is that everybody else being brave while they endure that?

Like, what about this version of the movie was the “brave new world” we were supposed to be embracing or whatever. Like, I feel like to me, I didn’t see if, if that is what we’re calling being brave. Then I’m disappointed in Marvel for taking that stance. If, if there was some other brave new world we were supposed to be embracing, then I’m, I’m upset with Marvel for not making that clearer.

Staci, you bring up Bridgerton, but I think the difference there is that Shonda said, I’m going to do it anyway.

Staci: Mm-hmm.

Marcie: Where Marvel said, we gonna tweak it to make it more palatable to an audience. And I don’t, to be fair and to be honest, with the success of Black Panther and Wakanda Forever, had the movie been what it was supposed to be, had we really seen had the people that saw it first really seen a, a great Captain America, had we seen Giancarlo Esposito- ’cause he can say he’s whatever he is, but when you were in School Days to us you’re part of the community- we would have been looking for that and we would’ve supported that in a different way.

But I think,

Y. M. Nelson: oh gosh,

Marcie: who saw it first? Then also from our own community started looking at it, kind of dulled the support that we could have for the movie, because we recognized that it wasn’t what we had been told it was gonna be, either. And I think that was also part of it.

So yeah, I think, I feel like the intentions were good and I feel like Perry in some way that I wish I could have seen the first version and seeing what they had before they started

Y. M. Nelson: doing the research,

Marcie: doing the research and and letting focus groups change what they know the story should have been. Because I think that movie I might- I didn’t dislike this one, but I think I would’ve loved that other one.

Y. M. Nelson: Marcie, before I missed this, there are two things that you said that really resonate with me. The first thing is the the fact that they- and you didn’t say this, but I’m gonna say it- the fact that they pandered to a certain audience and if they had of done a little bit a different target audience research and done a little bit different marketing, that they probably would’ve gotten a better response, ie. what happened with Black Panther.

All you had to do is tell us, Black Panther, Chadwick Bozeman. You showed us the trailer. The trailer is unapologetically Black. Right? And we knew where this was coming from. This is coming from out of the Marvel universe that is not all Black. We understand that.

We understand that it’s in the Marvel universe, but you give us this movie and what happened? You got the biggest grossing movie in your studios, basically, you know,

Marcie: and, and then we followed him

Y. M. Nelson: before End game, I should say, probably.

Marcie: And then we followed him through movies that

Y. M. Nelson: we did,

Marcie: was. Not in.

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.

Marcie: Because we wanted to still support the, the character. So, you had non superhero people still showing up for the movies in the middle.

Y. M. Nelson: Right.

Marcie: To support the character.

And then when it turns back around, we have this character. And one, the Marvel community can’t show up for a Marvel superhero in the same way, even despite being canon. We got that.

And then we’ve got a studio saying, we’ll change this, that and the other to make it more palatable to honestly people who probably weren’t coming anyway,

Y. M. Nelson: right, exactly.

Marcie: Who probably weren’t coming to a superhero movie at this point, anyway. And so, I feel like me as a frustration as a viewer was, we didn’t get the story.

And, and I think Perry, you said it like, I, I thought we were getting like the Serpent Society, I thought we were getting a Captain America movie where we were gonna see something. I thought when I saw Giancarlo Esposito in that first scene that we were going to get a through line, and he showed up almost like what was the dude? That Killmonger bought the the

Perry Constantine: Oh Claw

Marcie: by bringing from, yeah, he, he showed up almost like Claw. He just kind of showed up in a couple of places randomly throughout the movie, and we were supposed to be like, oh, I get it.

But yeah, no, I feel like that to me was a point where I was like. This isn’t the movie.

You, you, I think you finally verbalized it for me. This isn’t the movie I thought I was going to see. Yes. Because I thought the movie, I was going to see was that story. Yeah. And so, then I was waiting for it, and I got snippets of it, but as a, as a subplot to the Red Hulk and not as the story I saw I was coming to see.

And I think that’s part of it is I feel like I, I feel like the choices that got made on the cutting room floor were not the movie I thought I was going to see.

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. And the other thing that you mentioned was about the brave new world part and and the Captain America, Sam Wilson character talks about the fact that every time he goes out, he’s representing all Black people. And that is a pressure on him, and it’s hard. And probably every Black person that was in the audience when I went, I don’t know about all of y’all, but probably every Black person that was in the audience when I went was like, yep, yep.

Been there, been there. You know?

And if that’s what they were doing with the name. It is infuriating to me at this point. You know that you’re saying it’s a brave new world when we have a Black Captain America? Like, are you kidding me right now with this?

And then kind of to piggyback off what both you and Perry were saying, and Perry, I, I would love to hear you elaborate a little bit on this from the comic perspective. When I was going in, I didn’t think it was gonna be this much controversy because not only is this already in the comics for the comic book fans, but for us, Marvel we just came in with the MCU or we just watched the animated stuff, for us in that realm, this has already been established.

Steve already passed the shield over to Sam. He already did that, you know, and we have a whole series here of Sam actually becoming Captain America. So, we already have the through point. So why the controversy is beyond me.

And why the Marvel fans, the people who actually go in this because they are the comic book fans, for it to be in the comic books already and there’s still controversy is beyond me.

So, Perry. From a comic book perspective, are we seeing what’s in the comic books? Is this how it’s going? Or what?

Perry Constantine: So, a few things here. First off, the Brave New World title was actually a retitle. The original title was “N-w W0r!d Ord@r.” And what happened was, because there was a lot of, all that Q anon nonsense and all this kinda like conspiracy theorist nonsense ’cause n-w w0r!d 0rd@r, like a trigger word for them.

Y. M. Nelson: Yes, yes.

Perry Constantine: So that, you know, that caused caused Marvel to kind of, to change, to shift the title. And I mean, I don’t think they were trying to make a statement about it being a brave thing because it’s a Black man. I think it was just, that’s a common, just like that’s something that, that’s a common phrase that evokes the kind of same idea, and I think they just weren’t really thinking about that aspect of it as it came across.

Y. M. Nelson: This is why y’all need DEI, everybody!

Perry Constantine: Yeah, exactly!

Y. M. Nelson: I’m sorry. Continue, Perry.

Perry Constantine: No, no, you’re absolutely right. You’re absolutely right. But also, the, the whole thing about Sam as Captain America, and here’s the thing that drives me nuts about this. Because the whole idea of legacy heroes and heroes passing on their legacy and their identities to other characters that’s been in the comics for decades.

That goes all the way back to, you know, Barry Allen becoming The Flash in the 1960s, and before that it was Jay Garrick, and you know, then you had Hal Jordan as Green Lantern. Before that it was Alan Scott. The whole legacy thing has been a thing for a long time, and typically it is the partner who is the natural successor.

So, when Bruce Wayne hangs up the towel, it’s Dick Grayson who picks it up. And when when Diana hangs up her lasso, it’s Donna Troy picks it up, and so on and so forth. Like this has been a thing where it’s always the partner who picks up the legacy. They’re, they’re the natural choice for successor.

And if you look at the comics history, first off, when Bucky was gone for most of the, the time that Cap was being published. Like Sam in the comics, canonically has been Steve’s partner for a lot longer period of time than Bucky ever was.

Y. M. Nelson: Wow.

Perry Constantine: And so, when they’re looking to give the- pass the mantle to someone else, yeah, Sam is the natural choice for the successor.

And even the, in the movies it makes sense because Bucky has all this baggage from his time as the winter soldier going on. He’s not. He’s not the one who feels like he is the best person to represent this. He’s still got a lot of stuff he has to work with. Sam is the natural choice for the successor. So that, but it’s always the thing. It’s always- right?

This shows you what they’re really arguing against. They’re not arguing. This argument never came up when Dick Grayson was Batman never came up when Beta Ray Bill, the horse- faced alien was Thor, never came up when, you know, there was a new Green Lantern or a new Flash or anything like that. Never.

Y. M. Nelson: Right.

Perry Constantine: Never once came up. It only comes up when it’s a Black man or it’s a woman picking up the legacy of a white man. That’s the only time it comes up. And that shows you what they’re really arguing against.

Y. M. Nelson: Yes. Like Thor being a woman.

Perry Constantine: Yeah,

exactly. Yeah. Yeah. And they’re saying, “well, that’s, that’s his name.” Like, well, that was- there were other characters who also called themselves Thor, who weren’t that character too, in the comics, too. So, it’s just this, this kind of stuff drives me nuts about that because I’m like, we know what you’re doing. We know what you’re doing.

And this ties back into the whole with the outrage thing. You know, if you look at Marvel communities like on Reddit or something like that, where I hang out, most of them think all this controversy is garbage. Most real comics fans understand this stuff.

The people who are generating all this controversy and outrage, it is the, the trolls who make money off of this through clickbait. That’s really what it is. It’s, and it goes back to the whole Gamergate nonsense with Milo, whatever his name is, who got involved in the whole gamer gate stuff.

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.

Perry Constantine: Didn’t even like video games. Never played video games. He just, yeah, he just saw an opportunity for generating rage and then he capitalized on it. That’s what they all do.

back to top

[00:14:25] Casting Controversy

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Okay. So, anybody wanna say anything else about this controversy thing? ‘Cause I really don’t. I just needed to address it because it’s out there.

 What I, I really do wanna talk about obviously you know, we’re reviewing this. I do wanna give it a rating, but and, and we’ve also talked a lot about, you know, some characters that we saw, and we liked.

I love, you know, Carl Lumbly as Isaiah Bradley. I love, I love that, and I love the fact that they did bring him in. We already talked about Giancarlo Esposito, I mean. You know him as part of the Serpent Society. Seth Volcker, I guess is his last name. I mean, I thought he was gonna be the big bad guy. Right?

And then too Red Hulk is not actually the bad guy. So that was the other thing that in the posters and everything. You see Captain America battling Red Hulk and he’s not the bad guy. Right. You know, it’s very confusing.

But but you know, there was some other controversy in casting. Perry, you wanted to mention the Shira Haas, the controversy there ’cause I did not hear the controversy with her being cast.

Perry Constantine: Yeah, so the controversy with her is so she had an exemption for the Israeli Defense Force. For anyone who doesn’t know, Israel has, you know, a mandatory conscription, but she had a an actual exemption. She had a medical exemption, but she still volunteered for the IDF, and she’s been very supportive of Israel’s actions in Gaza and all that.

So, so that’s where most of that comes from. It comes from the fact that there was there was this, you know, that she was so supportive of what Israel is doing in, in Palestine, and so much so that she volunteered for this.

And the character in the comics, you know, is is a superhero herself. Ruth Bat-Siraph is the character Sabra, which is also a controversial term as well, because of its tie to Zionism. And her role was reduced because of all this controversy.

But honestly, I feel like this was someone that we did not need in this movie. I don’t think she even brings anything. You already have that Secret service agent, which would’ve given more representation too. I’m, I’m probably gonna mispronounce her name, but Xosha Roquemore, I’m not sure if I’m pronouncing that right-

who plays Layla Taylor and- who’s a romantic interest for Sam in the comics too, so that would’ve been something else to do. Like give her more, everything that Shira Haas did in this movie, Xosha Roquemore could have done just as well. You didn’t need Shira Haas. It was unnecessary. Talking about controversy. This was a controversy you didn’t even need. This is just a self-inflicted wound,

Y. M. Nelson: right! Yeah, yeah. Exactly. Exactly. I’m kind of glad I would’ve been like, oh, and then I would’ve been looking at, no, no, I can’t look at, no.

Wow. I mean so much here going on with this movie.

But but yeah, I think if we had been there and if we had written this movie correctly, if we had been given these characters and, said, oh, this is what’s gonna happen. Or even, like Marcie said, if we had just seen the movie before the first reshoots, wow. You know, that would’ve been, that would’ve been interesting.

You know, you kinda wonder too, at this point, if there is a copy of the movie, the way that it before the reshoots, so it could be kind of like a Zach Snyder’s Justice League kind thing, and they could put it out and we could see it, especially after all this controversy.

But I, I know how, Marvel Studios probably will do that. It’s, it’s not as chaotic as it is over there at DC. Or, or was, I mean, I, I dunno what James Gunn’s gonna do, but but yeah.

back to top

[00:18:28] Characters we wanted more of

Y. M. Nelson: But before we talk in credit scene, anybody have anything to say about any of the characters? I think we kind of went over a lot of the characters stories and, and things like that.

Perry Constantine: I got two things I wanted to add. First off is I really love Danny Ramirez in this. Like I, we didn’t get to see much of him in Falcon and the Winter Soldier, so Yeah, so I didn’t know what to expect and I wasn’t as keen on him picking up the, the Falcon suit because I felt like it’s too much of the same when they both have the basically a Falcon suit.

And I would’ve liked it if they’d gone, ’cause in the comics he actually becomes like a mutated bird like human hybrid type creature, which I think would’ve been a little bit more. Add some more variety if they’d worked that in somehow.

But those, those flight scenes were amazing! And I thought his interactions with with Anthony Mackie, I thought their chemistry was completely on point and I really enjoyed

watching him in this role a lot more than I expected to.

Carl Lumbly, man. He, I’ve loved him ever since m.A.N.T.I.S. Anyone remembers that TV show? Yes.

Y. M. Nelson: M.A.N.T.I.S. in the nineties? Yes. Yeah.

Perry Constantine: Yeah. I mean, he’s, he’s, he’s great. He’s the perfect choice for Isaiah Bradley, and I just wish we got to see more of him. Esposito. I agree, man. We, it’s kind of like with Mads Mikkelsen, they kind of was him. I mean, Mads Mikkelsen could, would’ve been the perfect Dr. Doom. Giancarlo Esposito, I think he would’ve made the perfect Professor X. And I think like they just wasted both these actors.

Y. M. Nelson: Yes. Oh, wow. Now you’re yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Okay. I’m about to go off here. Yeah, no, I totally agree. Some of the characters that we didn’t see enough of were some of the best characters in my opinion, in this. You know, and I think some of the story that we didn’t see enough of would’ve made the best story in my opinion too, which, you know, kind of goes into I think what my rating’s gonna be in in the end.

back to top

[00:20:27] Post-Credits scene review and explanation

Y. M. Nelson: But let’s talk the very end credit scene because I have thoughts. So, at the very end credit scene Captain America is talking to The Leader. And of course, The Leader is mentioning that the heroes on earth are not the only heroes in the universe, and there’s other people out there.

And so, as I was going out of the theater, I was like, hmm, I wonder exactly what he’s mentioning number one first. But secondly, I was thinking, wow, I don’t know why, but for some reason I was thinking when he went to The Raft, I thought he was gonna go and see Zemo. And I thought that was going to be a connection somehow to Thunderbolts* because of the Winter Soldier.

And, you know the last time we saw Zemo was in Falcon and the Winter Soldier when he goes to The Raft or whatever. So, for some reason I thought it was going to be Zemo, and it wasn’t.

But now that it is The Leader and that he’s talking about this, and now that we’ve seen Doomsday and we also know that there is, is that Avenger Secret Wars, or is it just Secret Wars?

Okay.

Perry Constantine: It’s still Avengers: Secret Wars, I believe.

Y. M. Nelson: Okay. So now that we know those two movies are on the horizon, is that what he’s talking about? Is that what he’s referring to? Are we just all, you know, what are we doing?

Perry Constantine: Yeah, that’s what he’s talking about. He’s referring to the multiverse saga. And honestly,

I didn’t like this post credit scene. I felt it was kind of a hat on a hat. It reminded me of the post credit scene at the age of Ultron where you see Thanos putting on the the gauntlet, and he says, “I’m gonna do it myself.” Like, we knew you were coming. We know, we know all this. This isn’t this isn’t adding anything.

And it’s the same thing here. This we’ve known about the multiverse stuff. We’ve seen enough of it so far to know there’s something else out there. And this was a chance to do something else, right? We could have done, like you said, like having a tie into Thunderbolts* would’ve been cool. Having something more with with Isaiah would’ve been great.

Like anything, anything other than, than this, which doesn’t add a damn thing to any of this. I, so I was really kind of annoyed by this post credit scene.

Marcie: Also, for me Y. M., I think you know this because I had to ask you about it.

Y. M. Nelson: Yes.

Marcie: But they embedded it too far down. And so, I didn’t even get to see it because I had been in the movie enjoying a libation and had to go to the bathroom, and I waited and I waited, and I waited, and I waited.

And it was the longest list of credits with the slowest music I have ever seen in my life. And apparently right after, I had to give up and make a run for it, the post credit scene was there. And I, I know you say they’re normally that far back, but I feel like they’re usually in the middle of the credits.

Not necessarily all the way to the end, because by the time I left, we had gotten all the way down to all the post location credits and the end of the music credits. Like I was almost, it was, I, I don’t think I’ve ever stayed that long to see the post movie credit, but I didn’t, I never saw it in the theater because I didn’t, I couldn’t last that long.

But having seen it on YouTube, I didn’t love it. I mean, I, I agree. Usually, it’s something different in the post scene credit, and I don’t think it was, I would’ve loved to see a recap of anything- the president and his daughter. Anything like, I, I just, yeah, I didn’t, it didn’t help me at all.

Perry Constantine: Have some, have Ruffalo reacting to some of this since, you know, there’s, these are characters from his movie, so

Y. M. Nelson: Right,

Marcie: right.

Perry Constantine: From not his, not because he wasn’t in that movie, but, but still

Marcie: something else something else from the Serpent Society. Some other mention of vibranium. Some, any, anything else would’ve been, yeah, more useful than that.

Credit.

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, I wanna wanna say something to Marcie’s point, but Staci, what did you, what did you think at the end credits?

Staci: It didn’t really matter. I mean, you didn’t, like I said, it didn’t do anything. It was just okay. And like, I watched it here at home and I was just waiting, and I think it was a lot longer than you said.

‘Cause I, ’cause my mood was like, okay, we’re gonna show the next show, next thing. I was like, wait a minute. Don’t do that. I gotta find, I gotta find this post credit scene. And when he said, hey, there are other heroes out there. And I was like, yeah, we know. I mean, it’s other hero. Okay, what, what more, I mean, it would’ve been better if they brought, ’cause they, you know, talked about adamantium or something like that.

It had something like a claw coming out and we were like, oh, you know, it’ll been something, if it was some, it was something more than that. You know, it could have brought in Mark there. ‘Cause it is just something else than that.

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah.

Staci: I didn’t know, like okay. Other characters like, yeah, they got three movies coming out.

What other character, what are the heroes you talking about? Give me something else besides that.

Marcie: Right. Let me gimme something to look forward to and Avengers the, whatever the new one is. Shadow Wars. What is it called?

Perry Constantine: Doomsday is the next one. Doomsday, and then Secret Wars is gonna be the one after

Marcie: Right. Gimme something to look forward to, to help me, you know, more than the season, anything. But that was absolutely useless. It didn’t tell me anything I didn’t already see in the movie I was barely liking.

Y. M. Nelson: Right, right.

And so, to, to Marcie’s point: yes, the end, end, end credits- because some of them also had the middle end credits, which this one had a middle end, middle credit, whatever seen as well-

but the very end, end, end credits usually is at the very end. But it’s usually something that really connects and really ties in or really intrigues you for the next thing, or it is just really funny, like when they all went to the shawarma plays at the end of

Perry Constantine: mm-hmm.

Marcie: Right.

Y. M. Nelson: At the end of Avengers, you know. Like, that was hilariously funny. Or like at the end of, you know, Guardians of the Galaxy II, where Stan Lee is on this rock and he’s like, I’m telling this story and y’all don’t leave me, or whatever. I was like, worth it funny for me. Or it’s either tying some, tying you into the next thing or giving you like intrigue.

Even with the, the other tie- in movie that we discussed, The Marvels, I mean that post credit scene with, you know, Monica Rambeaux and, and her mother. Wasn’t that her mother, Maria?

Marcie: Uhhuh.

Perry Constantine: Yep.

Y. M. Nelson: And, and then we saw, you know, the Kelsey Grammar Beast, you know, and, and we’re like, oh my gosh, oh my gosh! You know, everything’s happening.

You know, you’re having this feeling like something’s happening. But you are usually waiting for that, and when it comes, it’s like a thing, you know, like when you know Stan Lee was alive, you know, you were looking for Stan Lee. You know, it was almost like Where’s Waldo? kind of thing.

But this, yes, it had gone on too long. We had already seen another post credit scene in there. So, when we see this one, it’s, it’s just basically like a letdown because we already know that Avengers Doomsday is coming by this point. Because Dr. Doom was already at Comic- Con before this movie came out! You know, he was at Comic- Con last year. So, it wasn’t worth it, y’all.

I mean, I’m with you. I’m with you, Marcie. It wasn’t worth it, and it felt longer than it usually feels. So that’s another thing. And yes,

Perry Constantine: I mean, to Staci’s point, you know what I think would’ve been a great thing to do is have them talking about using adamantium for this new project called Weapon X and that was it. You don’t even have to have a new Wolverine in there or anything. You just mentioned that in there. You don’t, right. People would’ve freaked out

Marcie: just to mention

Y. M. Nelson: Exactly.

Marcie: To tie, he like to bring the story arc to push it forward past where- Yeah. Just a mention of it. I mean,

Y. M. Nelson: yeah, and it makes the whole brave New World thing.

It pulls that in.

Perry Constantine: Exactly that. That would’ve also worked.

Marcie: Exactly. This would kind of, I agree. Fell flat and didn’t, it didn’t push the normally the other ones were either the comic relief we needed or pushing the story forward and and ramping you up for the next one. But this one, I mean that- there was nothing. I mean, even the tone of the people talking didn’t give it any kind of I.

Y. M. Nelson: Right. They were just like, hey, we need to do this end credit scene y’all.

Marcie: “There’s gonna be some more. You think you’re the only ones? There’s other things out there.” But not in his threatening, usual kind of way. He been hyped the entire movie and now you just gonna sit there calmly on your prison bed and just vibe out with people you still don’t like.

It just didn’t, no.

Perry Constantine: Speaking of a Harrison Ford connection, this had the same energy of the narration that the studio forced Harrison Ford to do for Blade Runner. It had that exact same energy. It’s like both, both Mackie and and mm-hmm. The guy who played Stearns, I’m blanking on his- Nelson. They, they felt like they didn’t wanna be there.

It just felt like,

Marcie: right. Like, alright, that what I’m saying? You so, so this, I’m supposed to believe this is really you? Your nemesis visiting you on the other side of the bars and you gonna sit on the bed and not get all hyped like you normally would when you’re nemesis is standing in front of you and you trying to tell them that you might possibly still have beaten them ’cause you still know something they don’t know. And this is the level of energy you giving to that? Oh, come on.

Y. M. Nelson: Right? Yeah. And so, ends a very controversial and somewhat confusing movie at times.

back to top

[00:30:38] Goodreads Rating

Y. M. Nelson: So, let’s all see what we gonna rate this one. When we talk ratings, we are talking at five-star rating, and we are getting it from Goodreads because ideally, this is supposed to be a book podcast but do a lot of other stuff here.

So, your rating of One Star means we didn’t like it. Rating of two stars means it was okay. Three stars means we did like it. Four stars means that we really liked it. And five stars, it was amazing. And yes, you can rate in between. So, Marcie you had the last word, but what do you rate this one?

Marcie: Despite my gripes about what I wish it had been done better, I did really enjoy the first part of the movie, especially. So, the Carl Lumbly storyline that initial setup, I did enjoy seeing Joaquin Torres as the Falcon. In his little moments, I was hyped to see Giancarlo Esposito. So, for me, I’m probably gonna give it a three.

For the parts that I liked, and if it was at home, I would watch it. When it, when it, if, if you’re watching us and you haven’t seen it yet, you didn’t go to the theater like we did, and you’re gonna watch it on Disney Plus, it’s, it’s worth a watch. Is it my first watch? Maybe not, but if you’re if you’re diehard, definitely worth the watch.

And if you if you’re Anthony Mackie fan, I say go for it. It was, it was worth it to see it. I’m glad I was in the theater.

Y. M. Nelson: All right. Yeah. So, Staci, what do you rate it?

Staci: Can I hear those again?

Y. M. Nelson: Okay. Yes. One, we didn’t like it. Two, it was okay. Three. We liked it. Four. We really liked it. And five, it was amazing.

Staci: I guess two and a half. Okay. I thought it was okay. I mean, I’m not saying I didn’t dislike it or anything like that. It was, I mean, it was just like, okay, watch the movie. I didn’t leave it being overly like. You know, sometimes you get that whole feeling of you watched the superhero movie, you’re like, duh.

You just feel like, I didn’t feel that, but I was like. Okay. It’s all right. You know, I, if it comes, like I said, if it comes on Disney plus, yeah, I would watch it there. Would I spend my money on it elsewhere again? No, but I’ll watch it when, if it comes on Disney Plus, but even if I’m watched since I’m already watched it, it came on again, I’d be like, yeah, I’m good.

So that’s why I’m giving this two and a half stars.

Y. M. Nelson: All right then. Perry, what about you? What did you rate it?

Perry Constantine: I think I’d probably go maybe, maybe not quite 3.5, but not quite three. Somewhere between three and 3.5 I’d say is where I’d fall. Okay. It’s, it’s enjoyable. There’s some stuff holding it back.

I feel like I- where the CAP movies work best is like with Winter Soldier, when they focus on the geopolitical stuff and they really hone in on that political thriller angle. And this had those elements there and then they got cold feet, and they pulled back. And I feel like if they had just focused on the political thriller elements, the geopolitical stuff, I think this would’ve easily been a 4.4 or 4.5.

But that cold feed aspect drags it down.

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah. Yeah. I am going to echo a lot of what everybody is saying here. I’m going to give it in that same range, I’m just gonna say 3.25- in the middle of three and three and a half- I’m gonna say that for the movie itself.

I’m going to say for the performances of Anthony Mackie as Captain America, Carl Lumbly, as the first Captain America, Isaiah Bradley, for Giancarlo’s performance, for a lot of the characters that we were talking about, I’m giving their performances four and a half stars. Okay. I just, I think their performances, and if you haven’t seen this one, I think you should see it for their performances.

Right. The story itself and where the plot of the movie is going is just 3.25. It is, it’s not there. Like I said in the beginning, I think the pacing is off and I think part of the reason why the pacing is off as we have been finding out is it is not the movie that we thought it was going to be. And you know, I kind of echo as well what Perry said. If it was the movie that we thought it was gonna be, it would be a 4.5.

And I think too, the reason why I wanted to point out, especially Anthony Mackie’s performance and those kinds of things, I think I’ve been reading a little bit too much social media and too much online stuff that is focused on the fact that, you know, “he’s Black Captain America. Why are we doing this?” And “he’s, Anthony Mackie, do we really want-” and I’m like, are you kidding me? Yes, yes! You know, he’s amazing in this.

Marcie: I agree.

Y. M. Nelson: Okay. He’s good.

Marcie: His performance was stellar. He sold the struggle of being a superhero without superpowers in a way that made it look like it was a challenge, but didn’t make it look like it was a drudge. He sold real life superheroism in a way

Y. M. Nelson: yes!

Marcie: That I think maybe only he could have done with also that sense of humor and with also knowing when to inject that into certain scenes but also with gravitas that was needed in places as well.

So, I think yeah, if you if you look at the acting work, you can’t give him anything less than 4.5 stars. Yep.

Y. M. Nelson: Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I’m, I’m like, I can’t wait to see more of him in Captain America. I wish I had seen more of him as Captain America in this movie, you know, and, and more of some of the other performances.

But yeah. And so, here goes another Marvel movie in the books. I want to thank you, Marcie, Staci, and Perry for joining me in this discussion for even watching this movie for this discussion. Thank you for that. And I’ve already asked you back again, so I can’t wait to see y’all again for the next one.

Hi, want to get show notes from this and future episodes in your inbox? Then subscribe to Nerdy Romantics Newsletter. At Nerdy Romantics podcast.com/subscribe. Nerdy romantics newsletter not only has show notes, but nerdy and romantic wrecks and sneak peeks and exclusives of my spicy, nerdy romances and love, love stories.

I love talking sci fi, superheroes, fantasy, and romance books, movies, and shows with my friends. So, share this podcast with your nerdy romantic friends. Thanks for listening and for watching.

back to top

Want these show notes in your inbox?

Subscribe to Nerdy Romantics Newsletter


Discover more from Nerdy Romantics Podcast

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Share your love

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *